Though seemingly resourceful, Google Apps does pose serious drawbacks to the efficiency of any company. The free Standard Edition of Google Apps is limited to just 50 user accounts, leaving any extra employees disconnected from the facility with which all others can communicate and share information (2). Additionally, users complain Google Apps proves incapable of saving work when designated to do so, requiring a time and effort consuming reload to cure the problem. Furthermore, documents require manual association with folders, easily frustrating business owners whose efforts should be focused on the task at hand, not their network of Web applications. Even more irritating for users may be that when using spreadsheets, “when a cell in spreadsheet B is referenced in A, the values don’t automatically get updated” (4). Seemingly, only the users with a spotlight on team collaboration will be willing to bypass the error messages to see the benefits which Google Apps offer. For all other business owners, the defects will prove too bothersome, time consuming, and frustrating to overlook.
Appearing to answer the call for the defects of the Google Apps Standard Edition, Google launched the Premier Edition for a $50 charge for each user account per year. This version of Google Apps incorporates the needs of all business forms, not just small to mid-sized businesses, and grants as much as 25 gigabytes of e-mail storage instead of the mere seven offered by the Standard Edition. Google Apps Premier Edition even rids the page of the ads which sponsor the free version and lend such benefits as e-mail archiving and more configurable spam filtering (3). An important business feature of the Premier Edition is the improved latency and disaster recovery times, as well as the ability to access information from another data center location if their primary data center fails for any reason. The company also recently introduced a Gmail feature for BlackBerry users as a feature enabling access of email through Microsoft Outlook (1). The updates to Google Apps Premier Edition seem to emphasize the attempt by Google to tailor their software package towards businesses in an attempt to simplify everyday operations.
Many IT departments feel the cost of Google Apps Premier, as compared to Google Apps Standard, is not worth the upgraded benefits. Ultimately, managers must decide whether “some phone call support, guaranteed e-mail uptime, more e-mail storage and an API or two,” validate the $50 fee required each year from Google per user (2). However, the way in which Google Apps (both the Standard Edition and the Premier Edition) foster an environment for collaboration and the sharing of information seem to be reason enough to ignore the small hindrances of the programs. An environment which acknowledges the immense benefits of collaboration and cooperation will undoubtedly thrive.
References
(1) Lynch, C.g. "Google Apps Premier Edition Gets Key Improvements." NETWORKWORLD, 7 July 2009. Web. 17 Mar. 2010.
(2) Ericson, Richard. "First Look: Google Apps Premier Addition." Business Center. PCWorld, 23 Feb. 2007. Web. 17 Mar. 2010.
(3) Carr, David F. "Google Apps: The Free Version's Best Features." Forbes.com. 17 Mar. 2010. Web. 17 Mar. 2010.
(4) Woods, Dan. "Why Google Apps Need Fixing." Forbes.com. 26 Jan. 2010. Web. 17 Mar. 2010.
I agree that Google Apps premier seems hardly worth the 50 dollars per person that it would cost. While in theory the Google Apps seems like it would be beneficial to a company the shaky design and practicality seem to make it more of a hassle than an asset. It seems that their is a unique business opportunity for a large company like SAP or Oracle to provide a very small version of their programs for an affordable price that could manage the amount of users a small business would require. I don't think that Google Apps can cut it, but that an idea like this should be followed out.
ReplyDeleteGoogle Apps is ideal for small business, and in fact I work for an IT solutions company in Seattle which uses it for most of its functions. I receive daily emails about updates to Google Calendar or new documents on Google Docs. Right now the company only has 8 employees, but as it continues growing, a new system will be needed. I agree that $50 a person for a mediocre system is not worth it, but it is also much more complicated for young companies to built a network infrastructure that connects all of their employees, so Google Apps may be their only choice over the first few stages of the existence of their business.
ReplyDelete